Wisconsin Supreme Court Hears Congressional Redistricting Cases

The Wisconsin Supreme Court recently heard arguments in two cases challenging the state’s congressional district map. The cases raise different questions about whether the map is an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander or improperly limits competition in congressional elections. The court is now considering whether the challenges can move forward.

The two lawsuits make different arguments about the congressional map. The Bothfeld case argues that the map is an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander, while the Wisconsin Business Leaders for Democracy case argues that it is an anti-competitive gerrymander that protects incumbents and limits competition. Attorneys representing Republican members of Congress and the Legislature dispute those claims and argue that the cases should remain dismissed.

The current congressional map dates to the redistricting process following the 2020 census. In 2022, the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s then-conservative majority ordered a new congressional map using a “least changes” approach to the existing boundaries. The court later rejected that methodology when it redrew Wisconsin’s state legislative districts in 2023. The current lawsuits argue that the congressional map should also be reconsidered.

The cases reached the Supreme Court after separate three-judge panels dismissed them earlier this year. Those panels concluded that, as circuit court judges, they could not overturn a congressional map that had previously been adopted by the Wisconsin Supreme Court. The plaintiffs are asking the Supreme Court to reverse those dismissals and allow the challenges to move forward.

For now, the court is not deciding whether to immediately redraw Wisconsin’s congressional districts. The immediate question is whether the two lawsuits can proceed. Because ballots for the 2026 election are already being prepared, any changes resulting from these cases would be more likely to affect congressional elections beginning in 2028 rather than this year’s election. The Supreme Court has not indicated when it will issue its decisions.