PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) are manufactured chemicals that are found in many everyday products, including nonstick pans, cleaning products, paints, and firefighting foam. PFAS are present in the bloodstream of 98 percent of Americans. Competing studies debate whether or not PFAS have negative health effects, and, if they do, at what level they are harmful. The federal Environmental Protection Agency has declined to regulate PFAS in drinking water. Meanwhile, some states are choosing to implement regulations independently. Hamilton Consulting closely monitors regulatory developments related to PFAS both at the state and federal level. Click on the links below for more information on PFAS regulations.
Regulatory: DHS has announced a recommended groundwater standard of 20 ppt combined for PFOA and PFOS. The recommendation now must go through the DNR rulemaking process before it is enforceable. DHS also recommends that the NR140 Groundwater Quality Public Health Preventive Action Limit for PFOA and PFOS be set at 10% of the enforcement standard “because PFOA and PFOS have been shown to have carcinogenic, teratogenic, and interactive effects.” At just 2 ppt, the Preventive Action Limit would be the strictest PFAS standard in the world.
The DNR board has approved three scope statements under which DNR will write rules to regulate PFAS chemicals. Read comments on the scope statements here.
Scope statements are the first step in the rulemaking process, which DNR estimates takes about 30 months. The scope statements would:
With the scope statements approved, DNR can begin work on drafting the rules and economic impact analyses.
DNR has already asked municipal wastewater treatment plants to test water flowing in and out of facilities for PFAS.
DNR has convened a PFAS technical advisory group, meeting on a quarterly basis.
Legislation: Several bills addressing PFAS were introduced in the Wisconsin Legislature during the 2019-20 Legislative Session:
Assembly Amendment 2 to SB 559 Rep. Rob Swearingen (R-Rhinelander)
The amendment directs a UW System study on PFAS, directs DNR to test municipal water systems and private wells for PFOS and PFOA and provide clean drinking water in affected areas, directs DNR to recoup payments for testing, investigation, and clean water from responsible parties who have used firefighting foam, and directs DNR to set lab certification standards.
SB 772 & SB 773/AB 843 & AB 842 Rep. John Nygren (R-Marinette) & Sen. Dave Hansen (D-Green Bay)
Similar to the CLEAR Act, the bill would give the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) extremely broad authority to establish and enforce various PFAS standards. A coalition of industry groups are opposing the legislation: Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce testimony. Wisconsin Civil Justice Council testimony. Water Quality Coalition memo.
SB 774 and SB 775 Sen. Rob Cowles (R-Green Bay)
The bill would allow DNR to regulate PFAS in “PFAS management zones” that have water testing above 70 ppt. This bill would not set statewide standards for PFAS chemicals.
SB 310/AB 323 Rep. John Nygren (R-Marinette) & Sen. Rob Cowles (R-Green Bay) – Signed Into Law
The bill would prohibit the use of fire fighting foams that contain intentionally added PFAS in training, unless the testing facility has appropriate containment and treatment measures (as determined by Department of Natural Resources (DNR) rule). DNR has begun rulemaking to implement these provisions (Scope Statement 015-20).
SB 302/AB 321 Sen. Mark Miller (D-Monona), Sen. Dave Hansen (D-Green Bay), Rep. Chris Taylor (D-Madison), Rep. Stausch Gruszynski (D-Green Bay) & Rep. Melissa Sargent (D-Madison)
Known as the “CLEAR ACT,” the bill would require DNR to establish and enforce PFAS standards by rule for drinking water, groundwater, surface water, air, solid waste, beds of navigable waters, and soil and sediment if DNR deems it harmful to human health or the environment. The bill also provides that DNR may require entities possessing PFAS to provide proof of financial responsibility for remediation of potential discharge. Additionally, the bill requires any facility under investigation by DNR to provide DNR with access to information related to transportation of hazardous waste to any other site. The bill provides 7.5 positions at DNR and 2 positions at DHS, plus $150,000 for identifying and prioritizing PFAS sources, $50,000 for a study on use of fire fighting foam containing PFAS, $87,000 for testing landfills and leachate, and $120,000 for investigation of PFAS sources and providing drinking water.
SB 717/AB 792 Rep. Timothy Ramthun (R-Campbellsport) and others
The bill provides $250,000 for the Department of Trade, Agriculture & Consumer Protection (DATCP) to administer, with DNR, a voluntary program to collect and store or dispose of firefighting foam containing PFAS. This bill was introduced by the Speaker’s Task Force on Water Quality.
AB 952 Rep. Staush Gruszynski (D-Green Bay)
This bill would require DNR to determine whether a safer alternative exists for PFAS in food packaging. If DNR determines there is a safer alternative, no person can manufacture, sell or distribute food packaging containing PFAS.
2019-21 State Budget: The state budget included two positions for PFAS and other emerging contaminants research at DNR. The budget also included $150,000 GPR to develop a model to identify and prioritize sites with likely PFAS contamination and $50,000 to conduct a survey on emergency response use of PFAS-containing firefighting foam.
PFAS Update: Natural Resources Board Tables Emergency Firefighting Foam Bill and WisPAC Releases Draft Action Plan August 14, 2020
PFAS Update: Drinking Water Rules Advisory Group, Agency Council Meet July 17, 2020
PFAS Update: AG Kaul Leads Coalition Supporting EPA Regulation, WI PFAS Action Council Meets June 18, 2020
PFAS Update: Status of PFAS Legislation, Agency Council Meets, EPA Action February 21, 2020
PFAS Update: Regulations Moving in Legislature & DNR January 27, 2020
PFAS Update: AG Holds Listening Session in Marinette, Foam Bill Passes Committee December 20, 2019
PFAS Update: WI Agency Advisory Council Meets, EPA Action December 9, 2019
DNR Holds Public Hearing on PFAS Scope Statements November 13, 2019
PFAS Update: DNR Board Votes on Scope Statements, Agency Water Recommendations October 25, 2019
PFAS Update: Evers EO, DNR Scope Statements, Hearing on Fire Fighting Foam Bill September 16, 2019
Water Quality Task Force Meets in Northern Wis. to Discuss PFAS September 16, 2019
PFAS Update: DNR & AG Kaul Actions, Industry Response to DHS Standards August 7, 2019
DHS and DNR Release Strict PFAS Groundwater Standard June 26, 2019
Legislators Circulate Bills Addressing PFAS May 31, 2019
Water Quality Task Force Discusses Agriculture & Groundwater April 5, 2019
Speaker’s Task Force on Water Quality Meets to Hear Agency Testimony March 22, 2019
DNR, citing PFAS, scales back Voluntary Liability Exemption Program January 29, 2019
The federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has released draft preliminary guidelines for PFOA and PFOS. The interim recommendations follow EPA’s PFAS Action Plan announced earlier this year. EPA is currently seeking comments on an advance notice of proposed rulemaking to add PFAS to the Toxics Release Inventory. EPA decided in February 2020 that it will regulate PFOA and PFOS. EPA has also proposed rules that would exclude manufacturers of PFAS from providing proof of financial responsibility under the federal Superfund cleanup law.
AG Kaul Asks EPA to Strengthen PFAS Regulations April 27, 2020
PFAS Update: WI Agency Advisory Council Meets, EPA Action December 9, 2019
EPA Releases Draft Interim PFAS Recommendations May 1, 2019
EPA announces PFAS plan February 14, 2019
EPA won’t regulate PFAS February 5, 2019
Hamilton on Twitter
Barron County judge today denied a request for a temporary injunction preventing enforcement emergency order limiti… twitter.com/i/web/status/13182…